As Beyoncé’s first country album, Cowboy Carter, became the best-selling album of 2024, the star faced an unexpected snub from the Country Music Association (CMA) when the nominations were announced in late September. Fans of the pop icon were outraged, but country music heavyweight Luke Bryan offered a more nuanced perspective on why Beyoncé might have been overlooked by the country music establishment.
In a recent podcast appearance, Bryan, who has been a judge on American Idol and is a prominent figure in the country music world, acknowledged that Beyoncé’s foray into the genre was widely appreciated. “Everybody loved that Beyoncé made a country album. Nobody’s mad about it,” Bryan said. However, he suggested that her lack of engagement with the country music community may have contributed to the snub.
A Tight-Knit Country Family
Bryan’s comments went beyond just the quality of the music. He explained that country music isn’t just about producing an album that sells or sounds great—it’s about being part of a community. “If you’re gonna make country albums, come into our world and be country with us a little bit,” he said, hinting that perhaps Beyoncé hadn’t fully immersed herself in the country scene the way some may have expected.
The country music world often operates like a family, where relationships and camaraderie among artists play a significant role in how outsiders are perceived. Bryan, though respectful of Beyoncé’s stature, hinted that awards can sometimes be as political as they are creative. “But come to an award show, high-five us, and have fun and get in the family, too,” he added, explaining that part of earning a spot in country music’s elite circles involves more than just producing a hit record—it means becoming part of the fabric of the genre.
An Insider’s Take on Industry Politics
In his remarks, Bryan essentially admitted that the CMA nominations process is influenced by how connected an artist is to the country community. Despite Beyoncé’s monumental success in other genres, she has yet to establish those same relationships within the country world. Bryan’s comments subtly acknowledged the industry’s gatekeeping tendencies, even as he praised her overall talent.
He did make it clear, however, that he wasn’t outright criticizing Beyoncé, saying, “And I’m not saying she didn’t do that,” but noting that her presence in the country music world may not have been as integrated as that of traditional country artists. His sentiment reflects a broader reality: country music’s tendency to protect its own, even from the biggest global stars.
The Politics of the CMA
Bryan’s podcast comments exposed a truth about the CMA and the industry’s recognition of talent: it’s not always just about the music. For someone like Beyoncé, who comes from outside the genre, establishing credibility within country music takes more than producing a best-selling album. It requires actively participating in the country community—attending events, collaborating with artists, and integrating into the social scene that defines country music.
This insider take from someone as respected as Bryan suggests that for an artist to be truly accepted, they need to do more than just dabble in the genre; they need to show commitment. He implied that Beyoncé hadn’t fully “earned her place at the table” just yet, despite her undeniable talent and massive success.
The Future for Outsiders in Country Music
Bryan’s comments also point to a larger issue of how country music views outsiders trying to break into the genre. While artists like Shania Twain and Taylor Swift have seamlessly crossed over from country to pop, the reverse—pop stars entering the country world—is much more challenging.
As someone deeply embedded in the country music industry, Bryan’s views reflect the genre’s cultural emphasis on tradition, loyalty, and a strong sense of belonging. Country music, as he sees it, is more than just a sound; it’s a family. And for any outsider, no matter how successful, becoming part of that family requires time, effort, and a genuine investment in the community.
—
Photo Credit: Debby Wong / Shutterstock.com