Eric Church’s headlining performance at the Stagecoach Festival in California sparked a whirlwind of reactions among the 70,000 attendees and countless others watching via livestream. Known for his dynamic stage presence and rock-influenced country music, Church surprised his audience with a markedly different approach to close out the festival’s first night.
Starting with a 20-minute delay, the scene was set not for the usual high-energy rock spectacle but a serene, almost spiritual experience. Seated on a stool in front of a giant stained-glass video wall, Church was joined by a 16-member choir and his long-time vocal accompanist, Joanna Cotton. The setlist featured a blend of spiritual covers like Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah,” Edwin Hawkins’ “Oh Happy Day,” and “This Little Light of Mine,” interspersed with snippets of secular classics from Tupac and Snoop Dogg, such as “California Love” and “Gin and Juice.”
This thematic fusion of the sacred and the profane left the crowd polarized. While some appreciated the unique and reflective nature of the performance, others felt alienated, expecting the usual hits and not the acoustic/gospel tone that dominated much of the 75-minute set. Despite a late return to form with songs like “Springsteen,” the departure from expectations led to a notable divide among fans.
The discussion continued well after the night ended, with social media and fan forums buzzing with debate. Supporters praised Church for the courageous set, calling it a deeply memorable experience, while detractors expressed disappointment over not getting the energetic performance anticipated. This division highlights the challenges and risks artists face when experimenting with new performance styles at major music events.
—
Photo Credit: Debby Wong / Shutterstock.com