The Substance: A Haunting Exploration of Fame, Youth, and Self-Destruction

As the body horror genre continues to evolve, The Substance, directed by Coralie Fargeat, adds a fresh and unnerving tale to the mix. The film, starring Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley, confronts the darkest corners of fame, vanity, and self-destruction, offering a thought-provoking reflection on the pressures women face in Hollywood. Released in theaters on September 20 and soon to debut on the Mubi streaming platform, The Substance has garnered significant attention, thanks to its bold storytelling, stellar performances, and visceral imagery.

Plot and Characters: A Dark Transformation

At the heart of The Substance is Elizabeth Sparkle, a once-iconic celebrity played by Demi Moore, whose star has long since faded. In a desperate bid to regain her youth and relevance, Elizabeth turns to an experimental, black-market drug—one that temporarily replicates her cells to create a younger, “better” version of herself. Margaret Qualley plays this younger iteration, Sue, with unnerving precision, capturing the allure and terror of self-replication.

While the premise has echoes of the age-old Faustian bargain, The Substance flips the narrative on its head by exploring what happens when the battle for control is waged within one’s own body. Fargeat, known for her audacious and visually striking storytelling, delivers a film that balances psychological depth with moments of grotesque horror.

A Critical and Commercial Success

Since its September 20 release, The Substance has performed solidly at the box office, grossing $33.6 million globally, surpassing its $17.5 million production budget. However, the film’s true success lies in its critical reception. It holds a 91% “fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with critics praising the film for its audacity and innovation. The critical consensus reads: “Audaciously gross, wickedly clever, and possibly Demi Moore’s finest hour.”

While the audience score on Rotten Tomatoes sits at a respectable 73%, the film’s boundary-pushing content and unconventional narrative structure have proven divisive for some viewers. Yet for those willing to embrace its unsettling premise, The Substance is a memorable cinematic experience.

Themes and Commentary: Beauty, Rejection, and Self-Harm

In an interview with The Guardian, Demi Moore explained that the film’s themes struck a personal chord. “The circumstances of a woman in the entertainment industry who’s facing rejection and deep despair—that’s something I’ve seen up close,” Moore said. “What really struck me was the harsh violence against oneself. It’s not what’s being done to you, it’s what we do to ourselves.”

This notion of self-inflicted harm lies at the core of The Substance. The drug may serve as a physical catalyst for Elizabeth’s transformation, but it’s her internal desperation and fear of irrelevance that truly drives her toward destruction. In many ways, the film serves as a chilling metaphor for the lengths to which individuals—especially women in Hollywood—are pushed to maintain their youth, even at the cost of their own identity.

A Cannes Triumph and Award-Winning Screenplay

The Substance made its mark early in the year, screening in competition at the prestigious 77th Annual Cannes Film Festival. Fargeat’s bold vision earned her the Best Screenplay award, further cementing her status as a rising talent in the horror-thriller genre. Her unique voice and willingness to confront the raw, often grotesque realities of the human condition have set her apart, and The Substance exemplifies her daring approach.

Coming Soon to Mubi

Following its successful theatrical run, The Substance will be available to stream on Mubi starting October 31, just in time for Halloween. For fans of horror that combines psychological tension with body horror, this is a must-watch. Mubi subscribers can dive into the unsettling world of Elizabeth Sparkle and witness a horror tale that is both timely and timeless in its themes of aging, vanity, and self-worth.


Photo Credit: Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.com