Nothing is as it seems this Halloween season. What’s scarier than unwrapping a delicious piece of chocolate and finding the candy isn’t as advertised? Of course, a bit of dressing-up in product advertising is to be expected, but how much embellishment do we allow before we call it a lie?
As NPR reports, that’s the question at the center of Florida woman Cynthia Kelly’s lawsuit against The Hershey Company, first brought in 2024, which makes Reese’s Peanut Butter products. Kelly alleges she bought the company’s “cute-looking” Peanut Butter Pumpkins with a jack-o’-lantern wrapping in October, believing that the candy in question would match the picture — only to feel tricked, not treated.
“This is a class action against Hershey for falsely representing several Reese’s Peanut Butter products as containing explicit carved-out artistic designs when there are no such carvings in the actual products,” the lawsuit states. The suit claims that the problematic packaging extends to Reese’s seasonal ghosts, bats and pumpkins, and it cites a number of YouTube videos of other people complaining.
Although Hershey hasn’t admitted that the lawsuit is the reason, the packaging now declares, “Carving Not On Actual Product.”
It is yet to be determined whether the case will make it past a judge, and Kelly is seeking at least $5 million in damages. While that may sound steep for a piece of candy, Anthony Russo — who is representing the case — said that this number is a necessary reality check. “Today, it’s a $2 item — tomorrow it’s your vehicle, the next day it’s your home,” he told NPR. “It could be your life savings or your nest egg that you’re saving for your retirement. It could be anything if it is not kept under control.”
Hershey joins a growing list of food brands being sued for false advertising. Taco Bell, Starbucks, McDonald’s and Subway have all battled claims in recent years.
Case in point: Russo’s firm is also representing the plaintiffs in a class action suit against Burger King, claiming that the company uses misleading advertising to represent its food items as larger than they are. Russo added that American consumers used to be able to buy things with confidence, but the modern squeeze for profits has come at the expense of the quality of some products. “And that’s really what is at the base of all our lawsuits, and our crusade is that we’re consumer justice attorneys.”
—
Photo Credit: Jennifer Wallace / Shutterstock.com
